//! Turek–Hron FSI2: the self-excited flapping flag — rung C2 of the ladder //! (omni-cortex `docs/turek_hron_geometry_decision.md`). //! //! Re = 100 channel flow (`U = 1`) past the rigid cylinder with the elastic //! flag at density ratio `rho_s / rho_f = 10`: the flow destabilises the //! flag into a large-amplitude limit cycle. Reference (FEATFLOW level 4, //! dt = 0.0005): `ux(A) = −14.85 ± 12.70 mm [3.86 Hz]`, //! `uy(A) = 1.30 ± 81.6 mm [1.93 Hz]`, drag `215.06 ± 77.65`, //! lift `0.61 ± 237.8`. //! //! # The march //! //! Unlike FSI1's steady fixed point, FSI2 marches in time: per TIME STEP //! the fluid step and the flag's nonlinear-Newmark step are subiterated //! until the end-of-step interface displacement converges — the coupled //! piston benchmark's structure, with the real 2-D solvers. The fluid //! step is re-runnable inside a subiteration through //! [`EmbeddedPisoSolver::snapshot`]/`restore` plus a [`FlowField`] clone; //! the flag step is re-runnable because [`NonlinearDynamicStepper::step`] //! commits nothing. The moving polygon carries the flag's actual interface //! velocity — finite-differenced end-of-step positions over `dt`, //! interpolated along the nearest edge (`polygon_interface_velocity`) — //! replacing the zero-velocity closure FSI1's steady case allowed. The //! fluid keeps TVD convection (shedding physics; limiter chatter is //! harmless in time marching) and the multigrid projection. //! //! The geometry, load sampling (spike clamp + optional surface //! smoothing), fluid configuration and the march itself live in //! `fsi2_harness/` (shared with FSI3); the interface-noise-floor probe //! `fsi2_interface_noise.rs` measures the same machinery's pass-to-pass //! continuity. //! //! # Phases (the validation ladder inside FSI2) //! //! 1. **Rigid flag** to `t_release`: the ramped inflow over the fixed //! geometry must land near the CFD2 steady state this solver already //! measured (surface drag 121.4 / 123.3 at ny = 62 / 82 vs its CFD2 //! runs' ~121 / 122.6) — the harness's fluid configuration is checked //! against a known number before anything couples. //! 2. **Release**: the flag starts at rest under the sampled fluid load //! (consistent initial acceleration), and the coupled march runs to //! `t_end`. //! //! # What the 2026-08-21 study measured at the loose default (t = 30 s) //! //! **At the loosely-coupled default (8 fluid substeps per coupled step, //! per-step Aitken, ~1 subiteration) the coupled system self-excites but //! lands in a wake-forced cycle at 3.729 / 3.728 Hz with uy(A) ± 17.3 mm //! at BOTH ny = 62 and ny = 82 — grid-converged, protocol-independent. //! This is NOT the benchmark's cycle** (1.93 Hz, ± 81.6 mm). The //! identification is clean: the flag's vacuum mode 2 is 1.9245 Hz (modal //! analysis, 35x2 Quad8) — the reference cycle IS mode-2 resonance — //! while 3.73 Hz matches no structural mode (mode 3 is 5.26 Hz); the //! measured state is the heavy flag's off-resonance forced response at //! the wake's own shedding frequency, and its ux mean (−0.8 mm) matches //! the foreshortening scaling (amp/81.6)^2 x (−14.85). //! //! Why mode 2 does not win at the default coupling: the motion-load //! staggered phase lag (~omega dt_c) starves the resonant channel. The //! tenth session's attempt at tighter coupling (subcycle 2 at the SAME //! 2e-4 tolerance) blew up — the accepted interface scatter feeds the //! no-slip closure a wall-velocity noise of tol / dt_c, 30% of the mean //! inflow there — and was read as an impassable interface noise floor. //! //! # What the eleventh session (2026-08-21) measured: the mode-2 cycle //! //! The noise probe (`fsi2_interface_noise.rs`) showed the floor was a //! tolerance mis-budgeting: the real step map converges to ~1e-9 at //! subcycle 2. With the `IqnIls` coupler and the tolerance budgeted //! from that measurement (`RTX_FSI2_COUPLER=iqn RTX_FSI2_SUBCYCLE=2 //! RTX_FSI2_TOL=1.5e-5`), the march self-excites through resonant //! growth (2.34 → 2.23 Hz, drifting toward mode 2) into **the //! benchmark's mode-2 flapping cycle: uy = 3.7 ± 57.6 mm at 2.227 Hz //! at ny = 62 (t_end = 16), 1.99 ± 57.1 mm at 2.236 Hz at ny = 82 //! (t_end = 20) — grid-converged to 0.9% / 0.4% — and stable over a //! 24 s record (3.68 ± 55.9 mm at 2.224 Hz over [27, 30] s)**. The //! ladder localizes mode selection in dt_c: subcycle 4 opens the //! resonant channel for ~4 s (2.5 Hz) before the wake recaptures it //! (3.67 Hz, ±15.5 mm); subcycle 1 reaches 1.955 Hz / ±73 mm mid-growth //! (89% of the reference amplitude at essentially its frequency), so //! the remaining gap to the reference is coupling lag, not grid. Cost: //! 1.4 (subcycle 2) to 2.8 (subcycle 1) subiterations per step. //! //! Coupler failure modes met on the way, each measured and handled //! (`rtx_fsi::coupling` docs): stale secant history overshooting during //! rapid amplitude growth (history reset + one retry from the //! predictor), an ill-conditioned secant step sweeping a candidate //! interface to the domain wall (trust-region cap at 50x the //! residual), and a rare violent step near peak motion stalling an //! order below its own increment (accepted, counted, bounded). //! //! Robustness findings from the tenth session, both measured: rare wild //! tractions from near-degenerate reconstructions (19 samples in 2.4 //! million) killed a t = 25.8 s march through the flag's Newton until //! the spike CLAMP (20x the sample median, direction kept — clamping, //! not dropping: a hard drop makes the coupling pass discontinuous and //! the subiteration bounces at the step scale) and a 60-iteration Newton //! budget; with both, the same march runs to t = 30 clean. //! //! Machinery invariants asserted every run: load-transfer conservation //! (partition of unity) at 1e-10 (measured 8e-12 over 9,263 steps), //! coupled convergence bookkeeping, finite fields. The committed default //! (t_end = 7) pins the deterministic release response; study horizons //! pin the measured attractor of each configuration (the wake state at //! t_end >= 25 under the default; the mode-2 cycle at t_end >= 16 under //! IQN / subcycle 2) so any material change is loud. Full trajectories: //! the session scratchpad study logs. //! //! Environment knobs: `RTX_FSI2_NY` (fluid resolution, default 62), //! `RTX_FSI2_T_RELEASE` (default 6 s), `RTX_FSI2_T_END` (default 7 s — //! the committed onset segment; studies run 16–30), `RTX_FSI2_SUBCYCLE` //! (fluid substeps per coupled step, default 8), `RTX_FSI2_TOL` / //! `RTX_FSI2_RTOL` (interface tolerance floor and its //! relative-to-increment part), `RTX_FSI2_MAXSUB` (subiteration budget, //! default 12), `RTX_FSI2_FLAG_NX` (flag mesh, default 35), //! `RTX_FSI2_SMOOTH` (traction smoothing radius in multiples of the cell //! size, default 0 = off), `RTX_FSI2_COUPLER` (`aitken` default, or `iqn` //! for IQN-ILS with `RTX_FSI2_REUSE` steps of secant history, default 2), //! `RTX_FSI2_CSV` (trajectory dump path). mod fsi2_harness; use fsi2_harness::FSI2; use fsi2_harness::march::{MarchConfig, run_march}; // FEATFLOW level-4, dt 0.0005 reference values. const REF_UY_MEAN: f64 = 1.30e-3; const REF_UY_AMP: f64 = 81.6e-3; const REF_UY_FREQ: f64 = 1.93; const REF_UX_MEAN: f64 = -14.85e-3; const REF_UX_AMP: f64 = 12.70e-3; const REF_DRAG_MEAN: f64 = 215.06; const REF_LIFT_AMP: f64 = 237.8; #[test] fn fsi2_flapping_flag() { // The tenth-session defaults. The tolerance floor is the measured // interface noise floor of THIS configuration (loose coupling at // subcycle 8): the floor rides with the loads and with dt_c, and a // tighter coupling budgets its own (see the module docs and the // noise probe). let config = MarchConfig::from_env( "FSI2", MarchConfig { ny: 62, flag_nx: 35, t_release: 6.0, t_end: 7.0, subcycle: 8, tol_floor: 2e-4, rtol: 1e-2, stall_accept: 5.0, mask_hysteresis: 0.0, max_subiterations: 12, coupler: "aitken".into(), reuse: 2, smooth_in_h: 0.0, csv_path: None, snap_path: None, snap_every: 10, initial_relaxation: 0.5, trace_steps: 0, trace_from: usize::MAX, coupling_rescue: false, poisson_f32: false, coarse_episode: 0, inc_trace: None, increment_factor: 0.0, speed_fraction: 0.0, c1_interface: false, predictor: "structure".into(), quiescent_release: false, ffld_dir: None, }, ); let MarchConfig { ny, flag_nx, t_release, t_end, subcycle, smooth_in_h, .. } = config; let case = fsi2_harness::case_from_env("FSI2", FSI2); let result = run_march(case, &config); let w = result.window(3.0); println!( " loads over the window: drag {:.2} ± {:.2} (ref {REF_DRAG_MEAN} ± 77.65), \ lift {:.2} ± {:.2} (ref 0.61 ± {REF_LIFT_AMP})", w.drag_mid, w.drag_amp, w.lift_mid, w.lift_amp ); println!( " FSI2 (fluid ny = {ny}, flag {flag_nx}x2 Quad8, dt = {:.2e}, {}): coupled {} \ steps in {:.0} s wall total; {:.1} subit/step (max {}); {} stalled steps, {} \ history-reset retries (worst residual {:.2e}); worst conservation {:.2e}; \ skipped samples {} (of which {} spike-clamped); Newton rescues {:?}; coupling \ rescues {} (+{} failed ladders)\n \ measured over [{:.1}, {t_end:.1}] s: \ uy(A) = {:.4} ± {:.4} mm (ref {:.2} ± {:.1}), ux(A) = {:.4} ± {:.4} mm (ref {:.2} ± \ {:.2}), f = {} Hz (ref {REF_UY_FREQ}); onset amp {:.3e} -> {:.3e} m", result.dt, config.coupler, result.coupled_steps, result.elapsed, result.mean_subiterations, result.max_subiterations, result.stalled_steps, result.retried_steps, result.worst_stall, result.worst_conservation, result.skipped, result.spiked, result.newton_rescues, result.coupling_rescues, result.coupling_rescue_failures, w.t_start, w.uy_mid * 1e3, w.uy_amp * 1e3, REF_UY_MEAN * 1e3, REF_UY_AMP * 1e3, w.ux_mid * 1e3, w.ux_amp * 1e3, REF_UX_MEAN * 1e3, REF_UX_AMP * 1e3, w.frequency.map_or("n/a".to_string(), |f| format!("{f:.3}")), w.amp_early, w.amp_late, ); // Machinery invariants — asserted at every resolution. assert!( result.worst_conservation < 1e-10, "load transfer lost force: {:.3e}", result.worst_conservation ); assert!(result.final_state_finite, "flag state went non-finite"); assert!( result.mean_subiterations < 10.0, "coupling is grinding: {:.1} subiterations/step", result.mean_subiterations ); // Stalls at the noise floor are tolerated but must stay the exception; // a coupling stalling on most steps is not converging, it is drifting. assert!( result.stalled_steps * 5 < result.coupled_steps.max(1), "coupling stalled on {} of {} steps (worst residual {:.2e})", result.stalled_steps, result.coupled_steps, result.worst_stall ); // Physics bands, by horizon and configuration. The march is // deterministic, so short horizons carry tight regression bands; // long horizons pin MEASURED attractors — which attractor depends on // the coupling (see the module docs): the loosely-coupled default // (Aitken, subcycle 8) locks the wake-forced 3.73 Hz / ±17.3 mm // state at BOTH grids; the IQN / subcycle-2 configuration locks the // benchmark's mode-2 flapping cycle, grid-converged at ±57 mm / // 2.23 Hz. If a change moves any of these numbers, that is a finding // either way and must be loud. Smoothing changes the load path and // is pinned nowhere (measured to change nothing that matters). // Every physics band below was measured at the BENCHMARK case; an // overridden u_mean (the TWIN-1 sweep) or e_s (the TWIN-2 sweep) // pins nothing here — those bands live in the campaigns' composition // harnesses. The machinery invariants above stay asserted at every // inflow and stiffness. let benchmark_case = case.u_mean.to_bits() == FSI2.u_mean.to_bits() && case.e_s.to_bits() == FSI2.e_s.to_bits(); let default_coupling = benchmark_case && smooth_in_h == 0.0 && config.coupler == "aitken"; let mode2_coupling = benchmark_case && smooth_in_h == 0.0 && config.coupler == "iqn" && subcycle == 2; let s1_coupling = benchmark_case && smooth_in_h == 0.0 && config.coupler == "iqn" && subcycle == 1; if default_coupling && ny == 62 && flag_nx == 35 && (t_end - 7.0).abs() < 1e-9 && (t_release - 6.0).abs() < 1e-9 { // The committed default: the release response over [6, 7] s, // measured 2026-08-21 as uy mid 3.773 mm, amp 3.792 mm. The band // is ±35% for cross-platform floating-point drift in a growing // transient, not an accuracy claim. assert!( (2.4e-3..5.2e-3).contains(&w.uy_mid), "uy release-response mid {:.4e} outside the measured band [2.4e-3, 5.2e-3]", w.uy_mid ); assert!( (2.4e-3..5.2e-3).contains(&w.uy_amp), "uy release-response amp {:.4e} outside the measured band [2.4e-3, 5.2e-3]", w.uy_amp ); } else if default_coupling && t_end >= 25.0 { // Study horizons: the measured attractor of the loosely-coupled // (subcycle 8) march — f = 3.729 / 3.728 Hz and uy amp 17.3 mm at // ny = 62 / 82 (2026-08-21). if let Some(f) = w.frequency { assert!( (f - 3.73).abs() / 3.73 < 0.10, "uy frequency {f:.3} left the measured 3.73 Hz attractor \ (benchmark reference {REF_UY_FREQ}) — a material change" ); } assert!( (12e-3..24e-3).contains(&w.uy_amp), "uy amplitude {:.4e} left the measured ±17.3 mm attractor band [12e-3, 24e-3]", w.uy_amp ); } else if mode2_coupling && flag_nx == 35 && t_end >= 16.0 { // Study horizons, the mode-2 configuration: the flapping cycle // measured 2026-08-21 at t_end = 16 (ny = 62: uy 3.71 ± 57.6 mm // at 2.227 Hz), t_end = 20 (ny = 82: 1.99 ± 57.1 mm at 2.236 Hz) // and t_end = 30 (ny = 62: 3.68 ± 55.9 mm at 2.224 Hz) — two-grid // agreement 0.9% in amplitude, 0.4% in frequency, stable over 24 s. // The bands are wide enough for a settled cycle at either grid // and narrow enough that the wake attractor (3.73 Hz, ±17 mm) // or the reference itself (1.93 Hz, ±82 mm) would both fail: // either would be a material change to report. if let Some(f) = w.frequency { assert!( (2.05..2.45).contains(&f), "uy frequency {f:.3} left the measured mode-2 cycle band \ [2.05, 2.45] Hz (benchmark reference {REF_UY_FREQ})" ); } assert!( (45e-3..70e-3).contains(&w.uy_amp), "uy amplitude {:.4e} left the measured mode-2 cycle band [45e-3, 70e-3] \ (benchmark reference {REF_UY_AMP})", w.uy_amp ); } else if s1_coupling && ny == 62 && flag_nx == 35 && t_end >= 16.0 { // Study horizons, subcycle 1: THE BENCHMARK CYCLE, hit 2026-08-24 // (run 3, floor 4e-6, MAXSUB 30; measured over [13, 16] s: // uy 3.17 ± 81.68 mm at 1.925 Hz vs reference 1.30 ± 81.6 // [1.93] — 0.1% in amplitude, 0.26% in frequency; full record in // omni-cortex solver_status.md §"C2 closed in displacement"). // The bands are deliberately generous: the s = 1 trajectory // shifts legitimately whenever a structural-Newton rescue // engages mid-march (runs 1 and 2 DIED where run 3's coupler // fixes carried it), and the mode-2 s = 2 cycle (±57.6 mm at // 2.23 Hz) still fails both bands — losing the benchmark cycle // stays loud. if let Some(f) = w.frequency { assert!( (1.85..2.0).contains(&f), "uy frequency {f:.3} left the benchmark-cycle band [1.85, 2.0] Hz \ (measured 1.925, reference {REF_UY_FREQ})" ); } assert!( (70e-3..92e-3).contains(&w.uy_amp), "uy amplitude {:.4e} left the benchmark-cycle band [70e-3, 92e-3] \ (measured 81.68e-3, reference {REF_UY_AMP})", w.uy_amp ); } }